The NCAA Crack Down on Bat Rolling -1 Year Later

It has been a year since  Jim Paronto, the NCAA baseball rules secretary/guru sent out his memorandum on bat rolling -- that pesky compression process that "hardens" alloy and composite bats to deliver more distance -- and we were curious how many violations the organization has uncovered, and actions taken regarding individuals and school programs.

Here's the original memo:

VIA ELECTRONIC MAIL

MEMORANDUM

TO: Athletics Directors, Compliance Administrators and Head Baseball Coaches.

FROM: Jim Paronto, secretary-rules editor NCAA Baseball Rules Committee.

SUBJECT: Bat Alterations.

In an ongoing effort to provide an environment for fair and safe competition, the NCAA is sharing information it has received dealing with some non-wood baseball bats. It has come to the attention of the NCAA that there are several companies that offer to “roll” or “shave” non-wood bats in order to increase the performance of the bat. This type of alteration apparently improves the performance of the bat, in some cases considerably.

According to NCAA Baseball Rule 1-12-b: “Any bat that ... has been altered or flattened so as to affect the distance factor or cause an unusual reaction on the baseball shall be removed from the game.” During NCAA championship competition, any bat that is found to be in violation of Rule 1-12-b may subject the team and/or student-athlete to further sanctions under the NCAA’s championship misconduct policies.

Additionally, NCAA Bylaw 17.33 requires all member institutions to adhere to the playing rules of the sport in all contests. An institution’s failure to do so may subject it to penalties from the appropriate championship committee and may potentially constitute a violation of NCAA Bylaw 10.01.1 (Honesty and Sportsmanship) and 10.1 (Unethical Conduct).

The NCAA plans to collect and test bats at many sites of this year’s championships. Any bats found to be out of compliance or showing signs of altering may not be allowed in subsequent play.

Our email inquiry to Mr. Paronto has just been sent, so stay tuned for more info from his corner, and updates on our own inquiries around college baseball.

Understanding BESR Certification for Baseball Bats

The BESR

(Ball Exit Speed Ratio)

by

Dr. James Ashton-Miller, Dr. Michael Carroll,

Dr. Kenneth Johnson, Dr. Alan Nathan

NCAA Baseball Research Panel

Todd Petr, Ty Halpin

NCAA

Introduction

The NCAA requires that all nonwood bats be certified so as to limit their “liveliness.”

The certification process is accomplished by measuring the performance of a bat under

controlled conditions and then assigning a number to it; this number is known as the

BESR (Ball Exit Speed Ratio). To be certified, the BESR of the bat must fall at or below

a predetermined value set by the NCAA. This paper discusses the concept of the BESR.

The Ball-Bat Collision

Figure 1 shows a ball and a bat just before the collision and the ball just after the collision

(the position of the ball after the collision has been moved downward for the sake of

clarity).

Figure 1 The ball-bat collision.

 

The speeds involved in the collision are:

Vpitch = speed of the pitched ball just before it collides with the bat.

Vbat = speed of the bat just before it collides with the ball. This is the bat

speed at the point of impact.

Vball exit = exit speed of the ball just after it leaves the bat.

What Is the BESR?

The BESR is a number, once known, that allows one to determine the ball exit speed

Vball exit when the bat speed Vbat and the pitch speed Vpitch are specified. The relationship

between the BESR and these speeds is:

( 1 ) ( 1 )

ball exit 2 bat 2 pitch V = BESR + V + BESR − V (1)

`As an example, suppose the BESR for a particular ball-bat collision is 0.65, and that the

bat and pitch speeds are Vbat = 70 mph and Vpitch = 75 mph. The ball exit speed would be

( 1 )( ) ( 1 )( )

ball exit 2 2 V = 0.65 + 70 mph + 0.65 − 75 mph = 92 mph

Conversely, if one measures the bat speed, the pitch speed, and the ball exit speed, then

Equation 1 can be used to determine the BESR (see Equation 2 below).

Note from Equation 1 that greater values of the BESR give rise to greater ball exit

speeds. Therefore, the BESR is a measure of the “liveliness” of the ball-bat collision and

it includes, for example, any “trampoline” effect that the non-wood bat may display (due

to its barrel being temporarily deformed by the ball during the collision).

 

Where does the BESR get its name?

When one algebraically solves Equation 1 for the BESR the result is

1 ( )

ball exit 2 pitch bat

pitch bat

+

BESR =

V V V

V V

−

+

(2)

When the speeds of the pitched ball and bat are the same (Vpitch = Vbat), Equation 2

becomes

ball exit

pitch bat

BESR =

V

V + V

We see in this case that the BESR is equal to the ratio of the ball exit speed Vball exit to

the relative speed (Vpitch + Vbat) of the pitched ball and bat before the collision. Hence,

the name “Ball Exit Speed Ratio.”

How does the BESR Depend on the Properties of the Ball and Bat?

Figure 2 illustrates a ball just before colliding with the bat. The bat is assumed to be

clamped in a hitting machine and is free to rotate in the plane of the paper about the pivot

point.

Figure 2 The bat pivot point and the distance r

from the pivot point to where the ball collides

with the bat.

r

Pivot

 

The physics of the collision is described by applying the law of conservation of angular

momentum to the ball-bat interaction. When this law is used, along with the definition of

the coefficient of restitution (see below), we arrive at Equation 1, where the BESR is

given in terms of the properties of the ball and bat as1,2,3

2

p

2

p

+ 1 1

2

BESR =

1

e mr

I

mr

I

 

 − 

 

 

+

(3)

where

e = coefficient of restitution of the ball-bat collision. The coefficient of

restitution is defined as the ratio of the relative speed of the ball and bat after

the collision to that before the collision. Suppose that, before the collision,

the ball and bat are moving toward each other with a relative speed of

160 mph. Suppose, further, that after the collision the ball and bat are

moving with a relative speed of 80 mph. Then the coefficient of restitution

of the ball-bat collision is (80 mph)/(160 mph) = 0.5.

m = mass of the ball.

r = distance from the pivot point to where the ball hits the bat (see Figure 2).

Ip = moment of inertia of the bat about the pivot point. This parameter depends

on the mass of the bat as well as how the mass is distributed relative to the

pivot point. The more the mass is concentrated away from the pivot point,

the larger is the moment of inertia.

Note that the BESR depends on the properties of the ball (m), the bat (Ip), and the ball-bat

collision (e and r).

 

Why Use The BESR Rather Than Specify a Ball Exit Speed?

In general, different bat testing laboratories use different types of hitting machines:

(1) the pitched ball is moving and the bat is initially stationary, (2) the ball is stationary

and the bat is initially moving, and (3) both the pitched ball and bat are initially moving.

Even if each type of hitting machine is set up to have the same relative speed

(Vpitch + Vbat) of the pitched ball and bat, the ball exit speeds will be different. However,

all types of machines will give the same value for the BESR. This result, while not

obvious, is a direct consequence of Equation 1.

What Is The Maximum Allowed Value For The BESR?

When bats were first tested in 1999, an initial lot of baseballs was used. The tests were

conducted by using a pitch speed of 70 mph and a bat speed (at a point 6 inches from the

end of the barrel) of 66 mph. Under these conditions, the best major league wood bat

yielded a BESR of 0.728, which the NCAA then set to be the maximum allowed value.

The graph shows a plot of ball exit speed (Vball exit) versus bat speed (Vbat) for the case

when the pitch speed is Vpitch = 80 mph. The straight line represents Equation 1 in which

the BESR has been set to the legal limit of 0.728. Any bat that gives rise to a ball exit

speed at or below this line is legal. Likewise, any bat that produces a ball exit speed

above this line is illegal.

90

100

60 70

Vbat (mph)

Vball exit (mph)

BESR = 0.728

Vpitch = 80 mph

LEGAL

ILLEGAL

Subsequent tests on non-wood bats used different lots of new baseballs. Because the

properties of balls differ from lot to lot, even when they are stored and used in a

humidity-controlled room, the BESR is adjusted to account for these differences.

Therefore, the maximum allowed value for the BESR changes slightly, depending on the

particular lot of baseballs used in testing a given non-wood bat. However, in every case,

the BESR of the non-wood bat is always compared with that of major league wood bats

tested in the same machine with the same lot of baseballs under standardized ball-bat

testing conditions.

________________________________________________________________________

1M. M. Carroll, “Assessment and regulation of baseball bat performance,” Symposium on Trends

in the Application of Mathematics to Mechanics, edited by P. E. O’Donoghue and J. N. Flavin

(Elsevier, Amsterdam, 2000), p. 17.

2A. M. Nathan, “Dynamics of the baseball-bat collision,” Am. J. Phys. 68, 979−990 (2000).

3A. M. Nathan, “Characterizing the performance of baseball bats,” Am. J. Phys. 71 (2), 134−143

(February 2003).